Part 3: Aussie Housing Bubble: The Pain of our Delusions will be borne by our youth.

Philip Soos explains that there are three phases to finance:

"hedge, speculative and Ponzi. With hedge financing, income flows from an asset are sufficient to pay down both principal and interest on the debt used to finance the asset purchase, and prices are based upon intrinsic value. Speculative financing results in income flows covering only interest repayments, not principal, requiring debt to be continually rolled over. Investors may experience financial stress, but it is not widespread and fundamentals valuations are kept largely in check."

"with Ponzi finance, as income flows cover neither principal nor interest repayments (including running expenses in the case of rental property). Investors rely solely on escalating capital values in order to realise substantial capital gains at sale to pay down the cost of debt and balance their income losses. Asset prices are completely delinked from fundamental valuations at this stage. Investors rely upon ‘greater fools’ to maintain positive price momentum, resulting in a bubble. Once there are no more investors willing to take upon staggering amounts of debt to finance asset purchases, prices stagnate then collapse, as the market finally realises that prices are based upon a pyramid scheme, not fundamentals,"

So after reading my last two blog posts, you might be worried that in fact Australia is in a price bubble. Well with all the charts we have seen, have a look at this one.

How can anyone is their right mind think that house prices in Australia are based on real market fundamentals when the correlation of household debt to GDP ratio chart is exactly the same as the real housing price chart. I have overlayed these in photoshop for you to see.

There is not much more evidence you need to see that house prices are not connected to housing fundamentals of supply and demand, but they are instead connected to lending fundamentals of debt and borrowing. The more we are allowed to borrow, the higher the prices will go up. It is absolutely insane, and you should be angry.

Soos goes on to say:

"Another indicator is the rising levels of household debt used to speculate on housing prices. Household debt is overwhelmingly composed of mortgage debt, whereas personal debt is a small fraction. Figure shows the recent and considerable increase in the household debt to GDP ratio, peaking at 97 per cent in 2010 when housing prices did the same. The ratio has fallen slightly to 93 per cent, which may explain the falls in property values over the last two years, including the historically-low growth in housing finance data (Housing finance misses expectations in November, January 14)."

"A troubling fact is that almost 60% of investor loans are interest-only (25% for owner-occupier loans), signifying the speculative motive of property owners,"

"Investors were then dependent upon rising capital values in order to realise a profit at sale and to cover the cost of mortgage debt... This resembles the terminal Ponzi phase, where housing prices and the household debt to GDP ratio have boomed while net income losses have escalated."

"Accordingly, by these measures, the evidence suggests that the residential property market is currently experiencing a bubble, with prices detached from fundamental valuations... This appears to be the largest bubble on record, orders of magnitude larger than all preceding bubbles... When it does burst, heavily indebted property owners (recent home-buyers, negative gearers) will experience financial trouble, including the economy at large."

Professor Steven Keen recently commented on Today Tonight that what may cause the Housing Bubble to continue are "pollution refugees" who are wealthy Chinese investors that can compete in the Aussie market for new homes. This even playing field between the domestic and international players is one that is unique to Australia. In my opinion this is a slap in the face to the Australian public, not to mention a sloppy short-sighted way of boosting the housing market.

So do you have a mortgage? Remember that in bubble phase psychology, as the price escalates exponentially you go from euphoria to delusion. As the prices flattens out you go from delusion to denial. Following this we go from denial to fear as the media discovers the bubble is popping, and shortly after we go from fear to price capitulation. However I beleive the Government is willing to dish out more pain and suffering to those who have hopes of ever affording a home.

So who can we blame for this mess? Obviously as I have covered the main people to blame is the Federal Government through stimulus measures such as FHOS (or as Steve Keen calls the First Home Vendors Scheme) and providing policy to help leverage debt.

However for cathartic kicks and giggle I want to personally attack the seedy underbelly of this Housing Bubble  which is none other than the fat belly of mortgage lenders. Other than the banks this big belly has the big face of Aussie Home Loans, head up by Fat Cat John Symonds. So I have prepared some photoshopping to better help understand exactly how disgusting the people whom we decide to enslave our families to. (Note: all images are photoshopped and manipulated.)

Here;s your daily John Symonds inspiration for the day!

What about once he gets into his office? TRANSFORMATION. For all those Star Wars nerds you'll understand the quotes referenced.

Here is the link to Philip Soos Article on this topic that I referenced.

Part 2: Australian Housing Bubble: 3 Myths Debunked.

Myth 1: Australian housing is a great investment. FALSE.

This chart shows the Actual Real Rental Income on properties that are rented out by investors.

Since the expansion of easy credit has allowed for higher rates of speculation for investment returns on total house price, investors for the past 10 years have been willing to take on a Real Rental Income loss on their properties. This is amazing because it defies all rational logic for an investment. It means that investors truly believe housing prices will go up no matter what. This means that rental returns are no longer a driving force behind property investment, and total asset price-appreciation is the over-riding driver. They say that rent money is dead-money, but I would argue that housing investment money is foolish money, and renter money is patient money. It is cheaper to rent than it is too buy and the next point explain this further.

Myth 2: It's better to Buy than it is to Rent in the long-run. FALSE.

Not in this economy. Maybe 10 or 20 years ago, but im sorry generation X and Y but your baby boomer elders have sold you out. They lived on easy money and rode the debt train all the way to the end of their lives, and guess what ... they left you to pay for it all. How can we get revenge on them? EASY. Do NOT buy their overpriced houses. This will cause house prices to fall and leave them with negative equity, this means that Gen Y and Gen X wont have to pay someone else's bill's, and it means that we get our revenge at the last minute. Do you really want to buy still anyway? Well take a look at this chart below...

Sorry I don't have the figures for 2012 but I assure you nothing has changed. Now notice what happened in 2007-8. There was downward pressure on dwelling price-income rations, and we all know that this was the US housing Bubble popping and the GFC. US home-owners were stretched to their limits at a ratio of 2.7 before it collapsed. Australians are willing to live in the 4 to 5 ratio ... Do you know anyone who despite low interest rates still struggles to pay of their mortgage? Notice how the ratio for Australia dips below 4 towards a correction and then spikes back up. That's the effect of the First Home Owner Scheme, the Government stimulus designed to avoid the housing market correcting itself. The Government decided to kick the can down the road on a housing market collapse. This has only delayed the bubble bursting by fooling more and more investors into the market with their hard eared savings on house prices they cannot afford. This 4-5 ratio is of concern to the RBA who is keeping interest rates low, but unless incomes rise substantially it is not financially sustainable for Australians to be affording the cost of home-loans. Even at our historically low interest rates it is still increasingly expensive for people to enter the market. Cracks are already appearing in the housing market with fewer people taking up the FHOS grants. 

Myth 3: Housing is in high demand because of high population growth, and this supports future price growth. FALSE.

In Australia the annual dwelling starts index has always followed the annual population growth index. But there emerged in 2009 a massive disconnect as people started to swallow the red pill of reality. But the Government scrambled to produce blue pills of fantasy called FHOS (first home owner scheme grants). This brought the ratios back in line over 2011, but as you can see in 2012 this was drifting away again and now in 2013 it is drifting even further, and people are not taking the blue pill anymore. 

But you might be thinking that this doesn't make sense. How can more people not equate to more dwellings? Why can't I fix my computer with only just a hammer? Well the other week I went looking at the rental and share accommodation market in suburban inner-west Sydney. Through 10 different places I saw people renting our their living rooms, normal apartments converted to dormitories, and parents sharing rooms with their children whilst trying to rent out their only other spare room to strangers.

Its SIMPLE, people increasingly cannot afford to buy or own homes at these prices. Supply and demand only works when prices are affordable. You can raise the population all you want, but with real wages not rising in accordance with real prices you get jammed. The FHOS grants are not helping people, but rather inflating house prices and acting in a similar way that teaser rates were used in the sub-prime mortgage market in the USA. People need a dwelling they can afford and debt they can manage, and this means a new trend will be people choosing to share homes. People need to survive, and the government can only distort the marketplace for so long before the illusion no longer works.

Part 1: Australian Housing Bubble Visualized

"A bubble doesn’t occur because investors become fools, it occurs because fools become investors."

-         - Tom Woods 2013

This statement reflects the dangers of speculation in any marketplace. When Governments start stimulus programmes that encourage speculation, this becomes a direct intervention on the free market. Such an intervention is commonly seen as manipulation. Governments will do this to encourage economic activity through asset purchasing and debt accumulation. Australia is politically a see-saw and the Australian people are willing to jump between left and right in back to back elections. This means that politicians will focus on short-term economic goals such as boosting housing to avoid technical recessions.

This is the first of my 3 part series on the fundamentals driving the Australian Housing Bubble. Part 2 is already written and auto-scheduled for posting in one week and explored 3 Myths of the Bubble. Part 3 will target our mortgage lenders and photoshop will show them no mercy. For now i'm going to keep this post quite simple.

This blog is about the big bad bond bubble, but of course when shit hits the fan it is going to get messy in many other places. From the IMF to the UN everyone is warning Australia about its Housing Bubble, but the Aussie attitude is still "no worries, we've got mining, she'll be right." We are actually extremely vulnerable in the Australian Housing Market. Please click on the image below to get a bigger look at the chart.

Question: Is Australian Housing in a Bubble? YES

The blue line represent the Real Housing Prices in Australia since 1880. The red line represents the typical phases and trajectory of an asset bubble. Do you see any correlation?

1950's to 1980's: This bubble has been in the making for quite sometime, as lending standards allowed for easy credit to flow into the market for the second half of the last century. This debt accumulation has expanded exponentially despite typical financial cycles.

1990's: In the later half of the 90's as the tech bubble really took off, the media was giving massive amounts of attention to the ease of margin lending and the rapid rate of housing price increases. The media lived up to its image and allowed for the mania phase of this bubble to take off. 

2000's: Australia shrugged off the tech bubble bursting and put even more faith into housing. Enthusiasm led to greed and greed led to delusion. Even after the GFC and US housing bubble we still turned our nose up to the rest of the world and took the Governments free housing grant money and kept buying at higher and higher prices.

2010's: Cracks start appearing on prices and are labelled a "soft-landing." This is announced as a temporary flattening of housing prices. The term "soft-landing" epitomises the Denial Phase of any bubble. This will only lead to a bull trap in 2013- early 2014 as stock market rallies make investors believe that there is now a "return to normal." 

Predictions:

Towards the middle of 2014 you will see the Chinese Housing Bubble burst. This is now widely accepted as overdue, and mid-2014 is a conservative estimate on my part. This will lead to manageable financial turmoil and a temporary pull-back of industry in China. But they will need this correction as currently they have 64 million uninhabited dwellings. This temporary pullback will strain the Australian economy massively. 
The US Federal Reserve is expanding its money base at the rate of $85 billion per month, what this means is when we do business with the USA we are being paid in their rapidity depreciating currency. But essentially we are being paid in their inflation, and the same goes for business with Japan. Australia is finding itself as canon fodder in these currency wars and will be forced to raise interest rates as we import inflation from abroad leading to higher domestic inflation. 
The temporary recovery of housing prices in 2013-early 2014 will suddenly begin to collapse with all these factors and you will see the Aussie Housing Market begin free-fall collapse by the end of 2014, start of 2015.

Japan's Debt Problem Visualized

There is a great video on the mathematical inevitability of Japan to reach default. With the announcement they will double their monetary base in the next 2 years they are certainly hoping to get inflation. It is a really disjointed way of creating inflation because what happens is they will achieve high inflation in food & energy first and this wont be counted in official statistics (as they are considered volatile prices). This will start to cripple the populations future savings and thus investment potential, but the Japanese are willing to sacrifice their own whilst trying to attract higher returns from foreign investors because at the moment the 1% yield on government bonds is not so attractive. They problem is that they are wayyyy to late in the debt game to inflate their yields. With one quadrillion yen of debt accumulated, I'm sorry to say there is no going back, and no going forward... the debt is just too big, and so they will be going sideways until investors pull-out. I predict this will be in the next 12 months. 

Enjoy the video.